Skip to main content

Gardening References: Organic Fertilizers – Pros & Cons (Table)

September 4, 2024

Quick Reference for Organic Fertilizer

NameSourceWhen to UsePositivesNegatives
CompostDecomposed organic matterGeneral soil enrichment, before planting or as a top dressingImproves soil structure, adds nutrients, eco-friendlyTakes time to make, can attract pests if not well-maintained
Worm CastingsEarthworm castingsDuring planting or as a top dressing for added nutrientsNutrient-dense, helps plants absorb nutrients efficientlyCan be expensive in large quantities, slower release
Bone MealGround animal bonesDuring planting, especially for bulbs and flowering plantsHigh in phosphorus, promotes root and flower growthSlow release, not suitable for quick results
Blood MealDried animal bloodAt the start of the growing season for nitrogen-loving plantsRich in nitrogen, boosts rapid growth and green foliageCan burn plants if over-applied, strong odor
Fish EmulsionFish wasteAs a liquid feed during active growthBalanced nutrients, quick uptake, versatile for beds or containersStrong odor, must be diluted, may be expensive
Seaweed ExtractSeaweedThroughout the growing season for stress tolerance and root growthImproves stress tolerance, rich in minerals and hormonesLow in major nutrients, primarily a plant stimulant
ManureAnimal wasteBefore planting to enrich soil in large garden bedsImproves soil texture, adds organic matter, nutrient-richCan introduce weeds or pathogens if not composted properly
Chicken ManureChicken droppingsAs a compost amendment or after compostingNutrient-rich, quick-actingStrong odor, needs composting to avoid burning plants
Steer ManureCattle manureBefore planting or as a top dressingSlow-release, improves soil structureCan be heavy and difficult to spread, may introduce weeds
Organic Fertilizers, Benefits, Drawbacks and Overview Table


More From Our Master Gardener

Subscribe for updates

* indicates required